Mansur another question with the currennt campaign 1. Wondering why you did not roll on 9/18 at 330pm when the analysis suggested an upside roll. It ran earlier in the day on 09/21 when you added an upside roll earlier in the day. 2. Looks like another roll was suggested on 09/22 but you did not roll the calendar 3. When i look at todays message - SPX 7705.99 is above the downside level 7600.00 and below the active upside calendar strike 7750.00; no roll is needed. Using the chart you shared, losses seem to start at these levels 7685 and 7560 and on the upside it is 7825.
Following. A bit complex to comprehend but will get there. I saw the second trade was placed at 11am instead of around 10:30, SPX moved from 7725 to 7710. 1. Did you see something that made you wait until 11 ? i would have expected a different strike selection at 11am. And do you also target certain debit amount ? Are my strikes assuming a 10:31 tarde time correct ? sorry for the long question
Your interest and attention to detail genuinely motivate me—please keep the questions coming.
I captured the MID and placed a LMT order around 10:30 ET, and it filled at 11:04. The original strikes stayed unchanged while the order was working. After a few careless mistakes in the first campaign, I’m aiming for a more textbook process this time.
Your 7725/7685/7635 is a 40/50 shape; mine was 7730/7690/7635, or 40/55. My implementation also selects the upper long on a 10-point strike grid, using the earlier snapshot. Confirming your proposed setup would require the option quotes and Greeks at 10:31.
I don’t target a fixed debit: delta, spreads, and cost relative to risk guide the selection, then I use MID for the limit order.
And yes, it’s complicated! What keeps me excited is having a framework for different market directions without needing to predict SPX’s next move—while accepting that some trades will lose.
Yes. The dashboard will show completed reviews, actual executions, commissions, and the resulting campaign state. It will document what happened, but it will not operate as a real-time signal service.
Mansur another question with the currennt campaign 1. Wondering why you did not roll on 9/18 at 330pm when the analysis suggested an upside roll. It ran earlier in the day on 09/21 when you added an upside roll earlier in the day. 2. Looks like another roll was suggested on 09/22 but you did not roll the calendar 3. When i look at todays message - SPX 7705.99 is above the downside level 7600.00 and below the active upside calendar strike 7750.00; no roll is needed. Using the chart you shared, losses seem to start at these levels 7685 and 7560 and on the upside it is 7825.
Following. A bit complex to comprehend but will get there. I saw the second trade was placed at 11am instead of around 10:30, SPX moved from 7725 to 7710. 1. Did you see something that made you wait until 11 ? i would have expected a different strike selection at 11am. And do you also target certain debit amount ? Are my strikes assuming a 10:31 tarde time correct ? sorry for the long question
BWB Put
SPX SPOT Buy Sell Buy Debit
10:31AM 7724 7725 7685 7635 2.8
11:04AM 7710 7730 7690 7635 0.05
Your interest and attention to detail genuinely motivate me—please keep the questions coming.
I captured the MID and placed a LMT order around 10:30 ET, and it filled at 11:04. The original strikes stayed unchanged while the order was working. After a few careless mistakes in the first campaign, I’m aiming for a more textbook process this time.
Your 7725/7685/7635 is a 40/50 shape; mine was 7730/7690/7635, or 40/55. My implementation also selects the upper long on a 10-point strike grid, using the earlier snapshot. Confirming your proposed setup would require the option quotes and Greeks at 10:31.
I don’t target a fixed debit: delta, spreads, and cost relative to risk guide the selection, then I use MID for the limit order.
And yes, it’s complicated! What keeps me excited is having a framework for different market directions without needing to predict SPX’s next move—while accepting that some trades will lose.
I’ve read about A14 before, but I’ve never seen someone publish the full campaign. This should be interesting to follow
That is exactly the goal. I want the public record to show how the strategy behaves in live trading.
Hi! Will every adjustment appear on the public dashboard?
Yes. The dashboard will show completed reviews, actual executions, commissions, and the resulting campaign state. It will document what happened, but it will not operate as a real-time signal service.